Saturday, February 14, 2026
Home Blog Page 671

Is this any way to run a railroad?

0

Capital Goods – December 2007

Is this any way to run a railroad?
By Scott Mooneyham

You can’t live through an election season without hearing a candidate or two prattling on about how they intend to take on the "special interests" and return the government to the people. What about when the politicians and the government are the special interest? That’s the predicament that this state, and those elected to decide its policy, find themselves in because of the odd duck that is th North Carolina Railroad Co. The state’s oldest corporation, NCRR was created by the state in 1848 but partially owned by private stockholders. In 199, the state decided to buy them out, becoming sole owner of the 317-mile rail corridor from Morehead City to Charlotte.

Of course, there’s nothing really strange about government ownership of transportation infrastructure. But unlike roads or ferries, the railroad operates as a private business. It’s organized as a corporate real-estate investment trust. Its earnings, from leasing use of the tracks to Norfolk Southern Corp., are poured back into railway improvements and operations, not the state’s General Fund or primary transportation funds. State law also gives NCRR the same powers as private railroads. One of those: Railroads can’t lose property or easement rights to squatters. There is some government control of the company, but it’s exercised from afar. The governor and legislative leadership appoint the 13-member board of directors.

In an age of interstate highways and air travel, railroad companies today hardly flex the political muscle of their 19th century predecessors or provoke the same ill will from the public. For most railraods, it’s easy enough to keep their heads down, go about their business and assume that all that bile spewing forth about special interests is aimed at some oil or drug company. But lately, the NCRR is arousing the kind of animosity that was once reserved for robber barons.

The railroad, using the latest satellite-mapping technology, has been trying to enforce its right of way, claiming hundreds of businesses have encroached on the 200-foot-wide ribbon it controls. So far, the NCRR is not asking that businesses move. It is demanding that they pay rent – in some cases $1200 a year – and carry liability insurance. More than 200 businesses have signed leases. But the move has plenty of owners, many with deeds and property-tax bills showing ownership going back decades, hopping mad. Some have refused. Others are demanding lawmakers rein in this state-owned entity.

State Rep. Jeff Barnhart, a Cabbarus County Republican, sees the railroad’s acion as a money grab aimed at small businesses that can least afford it. Barnhart wants a legislative study committee to look at the dispute. "I’ve supported the railroad, but there’s right and wrong. This is just wrong," he says. But to find the culprit, he may need to look at himself and fellow legislators. In 2000, they gave the railroad power to lease right of way "for the purpose of preserving and protecting its railroad corridor and franchise," which is what NCRR President Scott Saylor says it’s doing. Most legislators probably had no idea what they had unleashed. Helping a state-owned railroad is one thing. Infuriating business-owning constituents – who vote, go to church with people who vote and otherwise socialize with people who vote – is something else.

Railraod officials feel confident that the law is on their side. But it’s not clear how well the law, and the circumstances under which it was passed, will hold up to intense scrutiny. The charter that established the right of way 159 years ago essentially voided any other land grants that might apply. Most – but not all – of the track ran through wilderness. Who knows under what circumstances some of the property was gained?

Even today, most of its right of way isn’t owned outright by the railroad. In 1995, in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing, then-NCRR President John McNair III wrote that the railraod controlled at least 80% of it by easement. Despite its charter, he claimed the right of way varied from 50 to 200 feet. "If Railroad operations terminate, the owners of the land may seek to have the easements terminated," he wrote. For this, people are being asked to pay?

But the dispute raises a more fundamental question: How does the North Carolina Railroad, as a state-owned entity, benefit the taxpayers, the people who own it? Would the benefits be any different if it were privately owned? For a few hundred of those owners, the question has been turned on its head. To them, the railroad – state-owned or not – has become just another special interest aligned against their interests.

Scott Mooneyham is the editor of The Insider, http://www.ncinsider.com.

Feedback + Comments

First Name :
Last Name :
Company Name :
E-mail address :
Title of Article :
Comment on this article :

It’s as simple as X, Y and Z

0

It’s as simple as x,y and z

Runner-up

GEOMAGIC INC. Headquarters: Research Triangle Park CEO: Ping Fu Employees: 93 Founded: 1996 Proj. ’07 Revenue: $20 million Business: Software & Services

Ping Fu set out to answer an esoteric question from a colleague. She wound up creating — and then running — a company that expects to gross about $20 million this year. The question came more than a decade ago while she was director of visualization at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications at the University of Illinois. “They wanted to know if it was possible to digitally compute space.”

That challenge, taken up by Fu and husband Herbert Edelsbrunner, then a computer-science professor at Illinois, has led to five patents and Geomagic Inc., which moved to Research Triangle Park in 1999. Using an optical scanner, Geomagic’s software creates exact three-dimensional images of objects. Automotive, aerospace and plastics companies rely on it for customization, quality control and modeling. Dental labs use it to make better-fitting crowns more quickly. Thanks largely to its dental segment, Geomagic posted a record 150% first-quarter revenue increase over the same period in 2006. Most of the money comes from software and services that support it.

Hearing-aid makers use it to shape their products, and one day it might be used to customize other consumer goods. Yet obstacles remain. Shoe stores, for example, would need expensive digital scanners to capture the contours of customers’ feet, says Cathy Hofknecht, director of marketing.

But Fu, 49, is used to overcoming obstacles. When she arrived in the U.S. in 1982, she spoke no English, had only $80 and had just been exiled from her native China for writing about the widespread killing of baby girls, a practice that resulted from her nation’s one-child-per-family policy (People, June 2006). She had planned to study languages at the University of New Mexico, but a man who offered to drive her from the airport to the university instead took her to a house with some other people. He left for several days and padlocked her and the others inside. They summoned help from a second-story window.

Fu later moved to the West Coast and earned a bachelor’s in computer science in 1986 from the University of California at San Diego. At the National Center for Supercomputing Applications, she initiated and managed the Mosaic software project that led to Web browsers Netscape Navigator and Internet Explorer.

Building Geomagic hasn’t been easy. Fu and Edelsbrunner moved the company to RTP after Duke University hired him. Early on, it received $500,000 from Fu’s sister and brother-in-law and $1.5 million from angel investors, but a management team brought in to run it had no experience with startups. When she took over as CEO in 2000, there were 50 employees. Three months later, there were less than half that. Two years later, it was profitable.

Geomagic software helped Fu’s adopted country ensure the safe return of the space shuttle Discovery in August 2005 by capturing images of missing or damaged tiles and allowing them to be re-created and replaced in flight. Geomagic also helped digitize the Statue of Liberty. If it’s ever destroyed, it can be rebuilt to its exact specifications. “America is my new home. It’s the country of freedom, and to be able to be involved with the technology to protect that very symbol of freedom is absolutely exhilarating.”

Pat Sullivan

0

Personnel File – December 2007: Women Executives

Pat Sullivan, Chancellor
UNC Greensboro

Despite her father’s misgivings, Pat Sullivan figured she would be a Latin teacher. “He wanted me to be an engineer, like him.” A favorite high-school teacher intervened, pointing out the limited opportunities for making a living in a dead language and suggested biology instead. That lesson shaped Sullivan in ways she couldn’t have imagined. Four decades later, as chancellor of UNC Greensboro, she’s in a position to mold the career choices of students, and making their education relevant to the modern economy has been a touchstone of her 13-year tenure.

The longest-serving chancellor in the UNC system, she has beefed up the sciences at UNCG — she hopes to push it into the top tier of research campuses, alongside Carolina and N.C. State — and boosted Gateway University Research Park, its joint venture with N.C. A&T. “I feel a professional and personal obligation to play a role in this area’s economic revitalization. We’ve been hit very hard with factory closures. As the biggest university here, we’ve had to be more of a driver.”

The native New yorker says this in the low-key way that has become her trademark. Sullivan, 67, eschews CEO peacockery for a researcher’s curiosity. Where many bosses expound, she explores. “I look at the university as a very large, complex organism,” she says. At the cellular level, it may mutate, moving, say, to more online courses, but core principles are encoded in its DNA: free speech, unfettered inquiry and wide consultation. Professors don’t take well to bossing. “You’ve got to persuade them, acknowledging their expertise. You’ve got to consult.”

If science shaped her mind, it didn’t satisfy her ambition. as a young faculty member, she worried about the relevance of her research. “At end of months in the lab, you’d wonder if you were making a difference. In my work with students, I knew I was making a difference.”

So, as administrative opportunities arose, she jumped. “I found them very challenging, not so much intellectually but personally and psychologically. You might put something in motion today, and nothing would happen for three years. You get your satisfaction from seeing the success of others and the success of the institution.”

Take the high ground

0

Take the high ground

The Sunshine State style of development casts shadows as Floridians flood into the North Carolina mountains.
By Cynthia Barnett

For a quarter-century, each July University of Florida Foundation officials have packed up orange and blue banners, balloons, Gator cups and other UF paraphernalia and driven eight hours to throw a party at the favorite summer getaway spot of some of the university’s most generous donors: western North Carolina.

So many Floridians now sojourn in the region that UF officials have had to split the bash into two parties over two nights. To treat the Carolina crowd to an evening of “bluegrass, barbecue and Bernie,” President Bernie Machen has to spend one night in Highlands and the next in Linville. “It’s grown so much, we’ve really maxed out the seating,” says Carter Boydstun, senior associate vice president for development at the UF Foundation. “Every summer, we have a lot more names to add to the invitation list.”

Whether chased by the heat, the hurricanes or property-tax and insurance costs, more Floridians are buying second homes in western North Carolina — or packing permanently for the mountains. And Florida home builders are following their customers north. Seeking to diversify as they ride out Florida’s housing downturn, the builders are buying up mountaintops and developing them by the thousands of acres. But they are betting on an uncertain boom. For in these cloud-laced mountains, Florida history is repeating itself in a dozen different ways. In some areas, speculators have lost money on deals that proved too good to be true. In others, rising land values and taxes are leading locals to sell out and move on, homogenizing the mountain culture as Christmas-tree crops become rooftops. Across the region, lack of development regulation has led to environmental problems, from groundwater scarcity to soil erosion.

“People move to western North Carolina communities because they think these small towns are so quaint, and then they perch a 5,000-square-foot house on the side of the mountain,” says Robin Cape, an Asheville City Council member exposed to western North Carolina on summer trips from Tampa with her grandparents. “I wish people could remember that they’re not in Miami anymore.”

Florida’s connection to the mountains of North Carolina dates to the late 19th century. University of South Florida historian Gary Mormino says those who could afford it began to leave coastal Florida each summer to escape annual scourges of deadly yellow fever. During south Florida’s real-estate boom in the 1920s, the Asheville chamber hired director Fred Weede away from the Miami chamber, “a clear statement that Asheville wanted what was happening in Miami,” says Western Carolina University history professor Richard D. Starnes, author of Creating the Land of the Sky: Tourism and Society in Western North Carolina. Boom towns like Palm Beach and Miami had proven that transportation — rail or road — was key to landing tourists and second-home buyers. Weede was among those who persuaded federal officials to route the Blue Ridge Parkway through North Carolina, excluding rival mountain destinations in Tennessee.

Throughout the 20th century, Asheville’s real-estate fortunes were tied closely to Florida’s. “You see many of the same people operating under different business names in both markets, and the same speculators speculating in both markets,” Starnes says. In the 1930s, “when the Florida market crashed, the Asheville market followed.” Starnes, North Carolina real-estate agents and others say they see a similar symbiosis today. “We can pretty much connect the dots,” says Tom Tveidt, director of research with the Asheville Area Chamber of Commerce, who tracks migration data for Buncombe, Madison, Haywood and Henderson counties. Tveidt’s research shows Florida is the top feeder state by far.

Southwest of Asheville in the rugged but upscale town of Cashiers, Realtor Jane Ebberts shows up for an interview looking ready for fly-fishing: jeans, hiking boots and a backcountry blouse. Originally from Buffalo, N.Y., she and her husband raised a family and pursued careers in central Florida, where she was a software designer. They came here in 1997, when he sold his security firm to a national company and retired early. “We really wanted to get back to all four seasons, but not Buffalo’s four seasons.” A friend recommended Cashiers. They came in May and didn’t want to return home, even long enough to sell their house. “It was love at first sight. It’s beautiful weather and a lifestyle, and you’re not going to get attacked by mosquitoes, either.”

The Ebbertses fall into a large demographic group known as halfbacks — retirees or others who come to Florida from the Northeast or Midwest, then move halfway back home, whether to North Carolina or another midlatitude state. Many halfbacks fall for the mountain weather: Average temperatures are 15 degrees cooler than Florida’s in the summer, with Crayola-bright autumns, light-snow winters and rhododendron-blooming springs.

More Floridians keep second homes in North Carolina than move here full time — in some cases to avoid state income tax. But the ranks of those like the Ebbertses who move permanently are growing. The annual number of Floridians switching to North Carolina residency rose from 13,578 in 1990 to 26,653 last year. While Census data doesn’t reflect a major exodus, moving companies are beginning to pick up a trend. In January, United Van Lines reported that for the first time since it began keeping records in 1977 it moved more people out of Florida than into the state. The company’s annual migration survey found North Carolina was the No. 1 destination state nationally, with a 64% inbound migration rate in 2006. Florida’s rate was 51.2% outbound, 48.8% inbound — a statistical wash.

So many Florida home builders are following customers north these days that they report running into each other on the ridges. Ebberts represents projects by Steven Umansky of Tampa’s LandSource Development, Ian Gail of Sheridan & Gail in Fort Lauderdale, Herb Gimelstob of Boca Raton and Mountain View Ventures, part of Resources Planning of West Palm Beach. Northeast of Asheville in Linville, Naples-based Lutgert Cos. began developing Linville Ridge near Boone more than 20 years ago; more than 70% of the residents are from south Florida. Other southwest Florida developers, including the Bonita Bay Group in Bonita Springs and Stock Development in Naples, say they are scouting development possibilities in North Carolina but cannot go forward until real-estate fortunes in Florida improve.

While all the Florida cash is a boon to mountain economies, it has created tension. Just as Floridians rely on European visitors even as they ridicule their Speedos, North Carolina’s mountain communities have long counted on Florida summer-tourist dollars while simultaneously deriding “Floridiots” who drive 25 mph on mountain roads where the posted speed limit is 40. In recent years, the concerns have become more serious than pokey drivers. Dominated by early-retiree baby boomers, the newcomers are bidding up land and housing costs, even as wages and job growth increase only slightly, says Tveidt at the Asheville chamber. As a result, just as in many resort areas of Florida, workers in communities such as Cashiers and Highlands that cater to the newcomers often can’t afford to buy homes there. Other familiar themes: sprawl, traffic gridlock, air pollution and loss of prime pasture and forestland caused by rapid, poorly planned growth.

In the most-rural mountain counties, conflicts are arising as developers import new, unfamiliar types of development, says Jody Higgins, a native of Yancey County. Higgins, publisher of the Yancey County Journal, says Floridians are an established part of the culture in such places as Pensacola township, where they have mingled with mountain natives since the 1920s, dwelling in modest cabins with spectacular views of Mount Mitchell and the Black Mountains. Several new communities, however, feature much larger homes and gated entrances — once unheard of in Yancey, a quiet, conservative county that continues to ban the sale of liquor, beer and wine. “Why would you want to live behind a gate in the mountains?” asks Cape, the Asheville City Council member. “There’s nothing to be afraid of.”

When it comes to importing Sunshine State grandiosity, no Florida developer is doing it bigger than Celebration-based Ginn Resorts. Ginn’s 6,000-acre Laurelmor, a luxury golf community that covers parts of Watauga and Wilkes counties, is larger than the nearby towns of Boone and Blowing Rock combined. With hoopla reminiscent of Florida land companies circa the 1950s, Ginn threw an opening party last November and flew potential buyers — many from Florida — over the property in helicopters. Buyers were impressed, snapping up 240 lots, ranging from $450,000 to $1.2 million, that day. But residents worry that the development will drive up home prices in their communities, which are increasingly unaffordable for families. Environmentalists fear Laurelmor will aggravate water-supply problems.

To ease environmental concerns, Ginn has agreed to put at least 2,000 acres, including 63 miles of streams, in a conservation easement. Other Florida developers also are setting aside land as part of community amenities. However, too many don’t, says Jose Rosado of Coral Gables, developer of Great Camps of the Smokies in Graham County. Rosado is CEO of IBEX Mountain Group, which has purchased more than 1,000 acres of wilderness bordering Nantahala National Forest and Great Smoky Mountain National Park and plans to build four communities with hundreds of high-end, rustic homes. Rosado has pledged 70% of each community will be preserved as wilderness commons areas. “A lot of Florida developers have been doing some real high-quality stuff, but there’s a few that have come in and done it wrong,” he says, for example, taking “checkerboard” plans and plunking them down in the mountains.

Rosado says Florida developers “by and large don’t have experience with steep terrain” and encounter problems with erosion and drainage. Most local governments lack laws, such as “steep-slope” ordinances, designed to avoid such problems. Some counties have no planning or zoning laws whatsoever. Fort Myers luxury-home builder Bill Ennen tells of walking into the Yancey County Courthouse, asking directions to the zoning office and getting a puzzled look. There is no zoning office. “People have been very opposed to any sort of subdivision ordinances here because property rights are sacred,” says Higgins, the Yancey newspaper owner. “But now people are suddenly seeing the mountains being chopped all to pieces, and there’s finally a groundswell to do something.”

Residents were debating growth and development issues in counties all across the Appalachians this summer. In a scenario familiar in Florida, newcomers often were the ones spurring on the local governments to act. Having found a slice of natural beauty and slow pace of life, the most recent batch of immigrants is trying to keep the next batch from lousing it up. Jackson County, home to Cashiers, took the boldest step when it slapped a moratorium on all new development pending a tough new subdivision ordinance, which passed in August. The high-end Florida developers supported the new law. “I don’t think anyone wants to see the mountains chopped up,” says Tampa’s Umansky.

Mitchell County has begun to discuss a subdivision ordinance — but only after a real-estate scheme at a development called the Village of Penland scammed investors out of more than $100 million. Developers, including one from Bradenton, Fla., used inflated appraisals and phony second mortgages as down payments and persuaded investors to borrow millions, promising enormous profits. The developers failed to finish a single home on the 1,200-acre project, using the money on other failed projects in South Carolina and St. Thomas, according to Attorney General Roy Cooper.

Having experienced a seedy side to the housing boom, western North Carolina is beginning to see a downside. Counties that had bucked the national housing downturn noticed a slowdown this summer that in some cases was tied directly to Florida’s. Every real-estate broker seems to have stories of buyers who couldn’t close on the purchase of a mountain home because they couldn’t sell a home in Florida. At Century 21 All Seasons in Asheville, broker-in-charge Joe Grady advises sellers not to make deals contingent upon a sale in Florida. He’s even advising his brokers not to bother with customers who have to sell their homes there: “Do not get them in your car; do not play chauffeur; do not give them the tour,” he says. “In our experience, it is taking them a long, long time to sell.”

Just ask Daniel Longen, 64, and fiancée Susan Brady, 60. Last year, with their Naples home on the market, they bought one in the western Asheville suburbs, looking forward to four seasons. When their Naples place languished on the market, the couple decided to put the Asheville home up for sale, too, and to live in whichever one didn’t sell. Two weeks later, they headed back to Naples. “I’m disappointed, but not terribly because Naples isn’t that bad, and people really seem to be working on the things we were critical of, like homeowners insurance and taxes,” Longen says. “But those mountain vistas sure were nice.”

Upper crust

0

Upper crust

Despite its success, quality and Old World charm, our Small Business of the Year kneads the dough.
By Amanda Parry

Blink and you’ll miss it. In the vast Triangle suburbia, along a parkway featuring strip malls and sprawling apartment complexes, sits La Farm Bakery. Flanked by a Papa John’s Pizza and a Caribou Coffee, La Farm oozes European charm in Cary. French music plays on a loop, 18th century wooden beams crisscross the ceiling, and head baker Lionel Vatinet, 41, calls out to people in a (real) French accent. Customers hear about the centuries-old traditions that go into the food. Images are evoked of simple village life, where breads were baked with local ingredients in communal ovens.

Beneath this Old World simplicity lies a modern business acumen. Not a local? Order online. Want to know more about Lionel? Read his blog. Seeing expansion possibilities? Talk to co-owner Missy Vatinet, who created a software program and training manuals to recreate the shop in any storefront in America. There’s nothing simple about La Farm or its success.

What opened as a two-person operation in 1999 has 27 employees. Sales have gone from $496,000 the first year to more than $1 million in 2006. The Vatinets, a husband-and-wife team, project revenue exceeding $1.25 million this year, 12% of which will come from off-site sales. In May, Whole Foods Market added La Farm breads to its Triangle stores, and restaurants such as Ruth’s Chris Steakhouse and Biaggi’s serve La Farm products. Internet sales were introduced after a mention on The Rachael Ray Show in March. An item in O, The Oprah Magazine, will tout its gift sampler.

“Just as there are recipes for food, there are recipes for business,” Missy, 38, says. “We wanted to create a system that would allow these artisans to do what they do best, profitably.” Their recipe for success has made them Business North Carolina’s Small Business of the Year. Judging this year’s competition were Ira Weiss, dean of N.C. State University’s College of Management; Kevin Schoolcraft, whose Matthews-based Masterpiece Staircase and Millwork Inc. won last year; and Ben Kinney, BNC’s publisher. All cited quality as a major component in the their decision. “A real story about returning to roots,” Weiss wrote in his remarks. “High-touch quality production of food in a time of mass production.”

La Farm carries handmade bread, pastries, tarts and sandwiches, all made daily on the premises. The staple is the bread, which comes in 35 varieties, including Asiago parmesan cheese and walnut sage. Everything is preservative-free, and local and organic ingredients are used whenever possible. The business is the perfect match of the Vatinets’ talents, he a formidable baker, she a veteran of the retail-food and restaurant industry. Their conversation about La Farm is as likely to include the terms brand platform and service infrastructure as pain au chocolate or yeast starter. They are hands-on with their business, a round-the-clock operation in which bakers begin preparing breads at midnight and the last sales clerk doesn’t leave until after 5 p.m. Lionel (pronounced LEE-onel) can often be found chatting with customers, encouraging them to taste different varieties and bringing them back to the baking area to show how it’s done.

La Farm has its origins in the neighborhood bakeries Lionel grew up with in France. A native of Paris, he got his first taste (pun intended) of the baker’s life as a teenager, when his best friend began dating a baker’s daughter. The three would hang out at the bakery sampling bread fresh from the oven, and Lionel began to imagine himself in the industry. He enjoyed the casual conversations between baker and customer, as well as the art and craft involved in shaping and baking bread. His parents, who ran a grocery store in the Port d’Orleans section, were eager for their son to learn a trade and arranged for him to spend the day as a baker’s apprentice. He loved it, and when he left school at 16 — common for teens pursuing vocational training in France — he was accepted into another apprenticeship to learn baking from the country’s masters.

He spent seven years breathing, sleeping and, yes, eating bread. He traveled the country and learned everything from how to shape dough to what bread’s molecular structure looks like. “A few years in, my mentor told me I was born to be a baker. I fell in love with the mystery of yeast and rising bread.” He graduated as a maitre boulanger (master baker) and a member of Les Compagnons du Devoir (The Companions of the Duty), a French guild that encompasses a variety of artisan and trade organizations and dates to the 12th century.

Vatinet took his expertise abroad, working as a consultant for restaurants and bakeries in England and Canada, as well as the U.S., Caribbean and Middle East. He eventually moved to America, training bakers and designing breads for businesses such as Panera, La Brea, Acme and Zabar’s. In 1994, he helped start the San Francisco Baking Institute, teaching artisan bread making. It became clear that not only was there a demand for gourmet breads but that it was growing. His perceptions weren’t wrong; Census Bureau figures show that sales of artisan breads increased steadily during the 1990s, part of a larger trend that saw Americans developing a taste for specialty foods. A growing economy and an increase in travel abroad were the main reasons, according to the Mintel Group, a London-based market researcher.

Lionel’s dream of opening a French-style bakery in America was starting to look like a decent business venture. Around this time, he met Missy Eide at a trade show in Chicago. A native of Syracuse, N.Y., she had grown up in Roanoke, Va., and had graduated with a degree in hotel and restaurant management from Virginia Tech. She began her career working for Austin, Texas-based Fresh Fields in 1992, opening branches in cities such as Richmond, Va., Charlotte and Washington, D.C. She went on to work for Brinker International — led by restaurateur Phil Romano — in Dallas, where she was part of a team that launched Eatzi’s, a chain of gourmet takeout shops. After three years at Brinker, she joined the Richmond-based Restaurant Co. and worked for Dick Ripp, whom she considers her ultimate mentor.

By the time she met Lionel in 1997, she had decided she wanted to start her own business. She quit her job, then took three months off to travel in South America. When she returned, Lionel suggested they open a business together. Missy wasn’t keen on the idea. She knew that partnerships have greater failure rates than individually run businesses and that personal partnerships do even worse. But his enthusiasm grew infectious. “I thought, if we could do the bakery business, we could definitely beat the odds for marriage,” she says. (They wed in 2005; by then, the business was a success.)

They traveled the U.S., Canada and France, studying successful bakeries and food retailers. They looked at the best markets, which seemed to be major cities such as New York, San Francisco and Boston. But it was when they researched up-and-coming ones that they found La Farm’s home. Seeing that real estate was doing so well in the Carolinas and Virginia, they ordered a $12.95 demographic study of the Triangle — where she had relatives — and found that the Raleigh suburbs had the right mix: middle-class, educated and well-traveled. The couple felt out “pocket markets,” spending time in neighborhoods. They chose a storefront in a shopping center along the not-then-finished Cary Parkway, banking on the idea that the road would guarantee lots of traffic past their place.

Setting up the shop became a family affair. Her father, a general contractor, came from Virginia to help with renovations. They were crucial to what Lionel calls the “theater” aspect of the business. He wanted customers to see the bakers at work and to be able to speak to them, just as he had at the bakery that inspired him. So they left the storefront open, with no wall separating the production and retail areas. Lionel’s parents flew in from Paris, and every morning his dad would help with the baking. Missy’s aunt and uncle, who live in Raleigh, also helped with the setup. They all took turns getting the word out by standing at the intersection in front of the shop, passing out samples to motorists.

The bakery opened in October 1999 with a simple menu: eight varieties of bread, including their signature sourdough, cinnamon buns, cookies and coffee. When the doors opened at 7 a.m. the first day of business, a line was waiting. In 31/2 hours, they were out of bread, and Lionel rushed to bake more. Using the only ingredients in stock, he created an Italian cornmeal loaf that customers still request.

Though the shop was popular, the timing was unfortunate. Soon after it opened, the tech bubble burst, and many customers began facing one, if not two, layoffs per household. One Mother’s Day, a man tried sheepishly to return a fruit tart he had bought for his wife, who had chided him for spending money for something they didn’t need. A clerk refunded the money but told him to keep the tart. A few months later, once again employed, he came back and paid up. Then the Atkins Diet came into its heyday, and some customers began cutting out bread. This trend reversed with the South Beach Diet, as its creator encouraged eating “healthy” carbs such as whole grains. The Vatinets introduced varieties such as nine-grain, spelt and whole wheat. By another quirk of timing, they found themselves trying to grow their business in the midst of anti-Gallic sentiment due to France’s position on the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq. But they can recall only one incident: A customer told Missy he didn’t like the French and was glad La Farm sold Italian bread. He bought five loaves. They weren’t Italian, but she didn’t correct him.

The Vatinets expanded their offerings, packaging mixes for items such as hot chocolate and crepes and began selling locally made jams and preserves. They increased the number of breads they sold but hewed to a formula Missy had laid out based on her experience in retail food. Knowing 80% of sales come from 20% of products, they came up with a core list of breads to be made every day and supplemented it with breads baked several times a week and seasonal treats. They continued to add staff, including an apprentice from Lionel’s guild in France. La Farm attracted many workers for whom English was a second language, so she created manuals with photos showing each step of a recipe or interaction with a customer. Copies — dusted in flour — can be found throughout the production area.

She also began taking steps to expand, creating a program to cost out recipes, giving potential franchisees a clearer picture of expenses. They looked at a second location a few years after the bakery opened, then decided to concentrate on one store. They did begin selling their bread at farmers markets, though this presents a challenge: Because La Farm can’t be classified as an agricultural operation, it isn’t guaranteed a stall. Markets in Carrboro and Greensboro won’t allow it to set up shop. At the state market in Raleigh, it is allowed to sell only if a stall is left after the farmers have their pick.

But loyal customers have rallied to the bakery’s aid. As the business grew, the couple was conscious of the need for a long-term strategy. Bill Weiss, CEO of the Cary-based Promar Group consultancy, went over their goals and how to reach them. One of his employees then helped develop a brand platform. Gordon Munro helped them set up a Web site. A photographer who splits his time between New York City and Raleigh, he didn’t charge for marketing photos and helped them find a graphic designer to redo their packaging. Consultant Rick Moore was so pleased to hear about their contract with Whole Foods that he delivers the loaves each morning in his car.

The Vatinets are focusing on growing LaFarm’s Internet business, in which customers are sent a slightly less-baked loaf wrapped in parchment with instructions on how to crisp it. The Vatinets hope to open a Raleigh store by early next year. They’re also working with a public-relations consultant, sending products and marketing materials to magazines and TV programs to get noticed, a tactic that secured them the mention on Rachael Ray — their cookies were featured as “Snack of the Day” — and in O‘s February issue, in which their La Farm Sampler will be featured as an ideal gift.

A PR specialist? Graphic designers and brand platforms? All this for a bakery? It’s becoming standard, according to Michael Kalupa, president of McLean, Va.-based Retail Bakers of America. “The days of the old-fashioned, white-paint bakery are gone. These days, it’s about color and merchandising, about grab and go, about whether the coffee is up to standard. They’ve really adjusted to the market.”

Trading big blue for girl scout green

0

Personnel File – December 2007: Women Executives

Rusine Mitchell-Sinclair

It’s not the way the cookie usually crumbles, but Rusine Mitchell-Sinclair, 55, stepped down as IBM’s top Tar Heel executive — the first woman in that post — to be CEO of Girl Scouts – North Carolina Coastal Pines, created by merging two councils covering 41 counties in the eastern half of the state. A 26-year Big Blue veteran, she was VP of strategy and implementation of IBM Global Services. The Raleigh resident now runs a bigger operation: IBM employs 13,000 in the state; the council has more than 32,000 girls and nearly 10,000 adult members.

Business finds fits for the pit_copy

0

Business finds fits for the pit

Runner-up

PIT INSTRUCTION AND
TRAINING LLC
Headquarters: Mooresville Managing Partner: Thomas C. Deloach Employees: 14 Founded: 2002 Proj. ’07 Revenue: $2 million Business: Pit-crew training and
corporate team building

While growing up in Statesboro, Ga., Tom DeLoach Jr. never saw a NASCAR race. He didn’t go to his first until 1986 as vice president of marketing for oil giant Mobil. “I said, ‘Wow, this is neat!’ Boom! The light came on: ‘I like this!’” Eventually, he became the company’s go-to guy for motor sports. Nobody got a sponsorship without his signature. When Mobil merged with Exxon in December 1999, he decided to take a lucrative payout and retire. “I couldn’t stand it. It lasted about two weeks.”

He bought a piece of Roger Penske’s NASCAR team, but when driver Jeremy Mayfield bolted for Evernham Motorsports soon after, Penske bought back his interest. DeLoach wanted to stay in racing, so he began knocking around ideas with buddies he had made, including former pit-crew chief and TV commentator Jeff Hammond.

Racing, of course, is big business, and pit crews seemed to be gaining importance, so he and Hammond figured they could make money training crew members. But they also saw opportunity in a more lucrative market: corporate America. They formed Pit Instruction and Training LLC in 2002 and jump-started it the next year by acquiring RGB Preferred Services Group, a Charlotte company that trained pit-crew members. DeLoach, 60, is majority owner; Hammond helps with strategy and lends his celebrity.

In 2004, the company moved into a new $6 million, 32,000-square-foot complex that anchors a 51/2-acre campus boasting a practice track with six pit stalls, a fitness center, meeting rooms, a dining room and kitchen. Last year, it made its first profit.

Those who want to join a pit crew — often recently graduated high-school athletes — take an eight-week course. The best might be hired by a NASCAR team, usually one with a tight budget. “They need a cheap pit crew, and we’ve got guys who need practical experience.” But most of Pit Instruction’s revenue comes from corporate training — customers include United Airlines, Intel, Best Buy and Penske Truck Leasing — and it holds the most promise for the company’s growth.

A day-and-a-half seminar runs about $50,000 per company and helps teach participants, among other things, how to organize to achieve a goal. The first session is a meeting that relates NASCAR to the corporate world. In the afternoon, participants change tires and simulate refueling with an empty gasoline can. (A full one weighs about 85 pounds — too heavy for many executives.) “We don’t let them jack,” DeLoach says. “I’m not about to let a corporate exec accidentally drop a car on somebody. That would have a real chilling effect on a training exercise.”

The first pit stop usually takes about a minute and a half. After two or three more tries, the normal corporate group will whittle that to about 45 seconds. After dinner, they watch the pros — who often make a pit stop in less than 20 seconds — at work. “Then they get to see how bad they really were,” DeLoach quips. The next morning is a recap of the main lessons. “I think we’ve got something that every corporation in the country could use,” he says. “My biggest problem is: How do I get to the right person to get that light to come on?”

Business finds fits for the pit

0

Business finds fits for the pit

Runner-up

PIT INSTRUCTION AND
TRAINING LLC
Headquarters: Mooresville Managing Partner: Thomas C. Deloach Employees: 14 Founded: 2002 Proj. ’07 Revenue: $2 million Business: Pit-crew training and
corporate team building

While growing up in Statesboro, Ga., Tom DeLoach Jr. never saw a NASCAR race. He didn’t go to his first until 1986 as vice president of marketing for oil giant Mobil. “I said, ‘Wow, this is neat!’ Boom! The light came on: ‘I like this!’” Eventually, he became the company’s go-to guy for motor sports. Nobody got a sponsorship without his signature. When Mobil merged with Exxon in December 1999, he decided to take a lucrative payout and retire. “I couldn’t stand it. It lasted about two weeks.”

He bought a piece of Roger Penske’s NASCAR team, but when driver Jeremy Mayfield bolted for Evernham Motorsports soon after, Penske bought back his interest. DeLoach wanted to stay in racing, so he began knocking around ideas with buddies he had made, including former pit-crew chief and TV commentator Jeff Hammond.

Racing, of course, is big business, and pit crews seemed to be gaining importance, so he and Hammond figured they could make money training crew members. But they also saw opportunity in a more lucrative market: corporate America. They formed Pit Instruction and Training LLC in 2002 and jump-started it the next year by acquiring RGB Preferred Services Group, a Charlotte company that trained pit-crew members. DeLoach, 60, is majority owner; Hammond helps with strategy and lends his celebrity.

In 2004, the company moved into a new $6 million, 32,000-square-foot complex that anchors a 51/2-acre campus boasting a practice track with six pit stalls, a fitness center, meeting rooms, a dining room and kitchen. Last year, it made its first profit.

Those who want to join a pit crew — often recently graduated high-school athletes — take an eight-week course. The best might be hired by a NASCAR team, usually one with a tight budget. “They need a cheap pit crew, and we’ve got guys who need practical experience.” But most of Pit Instruction’s revenue comes from corporate training — customers include United Airlines, Intel, Best Buy and Penske Truck Leasing — and it holds the most promise for the company’s growth.

A day-and-a-half seminar runs about $50,000 per company and helps teach participants, among other things, how to organize to achieve a goal. The first session is a meeting that relates NASCAR to the corporate world. In the afternoon, participants change tires and simulate refueling with an empty gasoline can. (A full one weighs about 85 pounds — too heavy for many executives.) “We don’t let them jack,” DeLoach says. “I’m not about to let a corporate exec accidentally drop a car on somebody. That would have a real chilling effect on a training exercise.”

The first pit stop usually takes about a minute and a half. After two or three more tries, the normal corporate group will whittle that to about 45 seconds. After dinner, they watch the pros — who often make a pit stop in less than 20 seconds — at work. “Then they get to see how bad they really were,” DeLoach quips. The next morning is a recap of the main lessons. “I think we’ve got something that every corporation in the country could use,” he says. “My biggest problem is: How do I get to the right person to get that light to come on?”

Burning down the house

0

Fine Print – December 2007

Burning down the house
By G.D. Gearino

Legislators returned to Raleigh talking tough. Democratic leaders fumed about Gov. Mike Easley’s veto of incentives for Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co., vowing an override. Some Republicans, suddenly finding the slippery slope of incentives to their dislike, spoke of gathering enough votes to sustain the veto. But as often happens in the state capital, bluster turned into murmur. No vote to override occurred. Instead, lawmakers approved broader incentives legislation that satisfied Easley, Goodyear and Goodyear’s top competitor, Bridgestone America Holdings Inc.

So will everybody now go back to their respective benches and allow the game to continue as if nothing happened? Maybe not. The reason for this tussle, after all, was that the original legislation represented a departure from North Carolina’s standing incentives policy. The bill would have allowed cash – up to $4 million a year for 10 years – to go to a business already here, with no promise to create jobs. In fact, the tire maker could even lay off workers. The incentives were provided because Goodyear agreed to invest $200 million for new equipment at its Fayetteville plant.

Easley’s veto brought needed public attention to incentives policy and created real debate about where and how you draw the line on who gets what. Critics condemned both the original bill and the compromise, calling each an invitation for business to blackmail the state. Critics have made similar complaints in the past. It hasn’t stopped the headlong rush into ever more lucrative – and to taxpayers, more costly – offers of tax credits and cash to prompt companies to move or expand plants here.

"There’s a tax-fairness issue out there. All of a sudden, people are starting to wake up and see this."

The complaints didn’t stop incentives this time either. The broader, follow-up bill actually upped the ante, allowing large, existing manufacturers to battle for up to $60 million in cash. Easley did get some worker wage-and-benefit criteria put into it, though qualifying companies could still lay off a portion of their work force. But the bill did trigger a dramatic shift in the political landscape. Nearly in lock step, GOP legislators voted against the follow-up bill. Just three Republicans in the House voted for it. None in the Senate did.

A few true believers on the Republican side, seeing incentives as something akin to socialism, had voted against such packages before. They were typically joined by legislators at the other extreme – liberal Democrats who look at incentives as having a reverse Robin Hood effect, robbing from the poor to give to the rich. But, starting with the job- and equipment-investment tax credits of the Bill Lee Act in the mid-’90s, this had never been a partisan issue. The overwhelming majority on both sides of the aisle pushed the green button when it came time to vote. Some claimed they were holding their noses while doing so, but it didn’t change the outcome.

Perhaps this latest vote will be an aberration. After all, it’s easy to vote against incentives when the threat of job losses doesn’t involve your community. Both the Goodyear plant and the Bridgestone-Firestone plant, in Wilson, lie in Democratic districts. There’s reason to believe, though, that the shift may not be tempo-rary. Easley and the Democrats just opened the lid of Pandora’s box a little wider. It’s safe to assume more companies will come begging, or threatening. The ultimate effect may be to bring more public scrutiny, and disapproval, of incentives.

Meanwhile, the largely party-line vote coincides with one of the leading critics of incentives, former state Supreme Court Justice Bob Orr, making a bid for governor. Not to be outdone, his chief competitors for the Republican nomination – state Sen. Fred Smith of Johnston County and Salisbury lawyer Bill Graham – issued public statements critical of the Goodyear bill.

Orr says his campaign is helping focus attention on the issue. "There’s a tax-fairness issue out there. All the sudden, people are starting to wake up and see this." His views may hurt him when it comes to raising campaign money from business interests. But Brad Crone, a Raleigh-based Democratic political consultant, says incentives policy could have the legs to become a wedge issue, helping a Republican peel Democratic votes from a Democratic nominee.

It remains to be seen whether that will happen, whether there is any vein of public outrage to tap. Should there be, and it’s exploited successfully, political support will begin to erode. Republican success will cause moderate Democrats to be more cautious about leading the incentives cheer. As odd as it might seem, electoral politics might begin putting the brakes on incentives in a way that supposed rational policy debate has not.

Tastes change

0

Tastes change

There’s a dash of old First Union in CEO’s new recipe for Wachovia.

By Irwin Speizer

In an office atop Wachovia Corp. headquarters in downtown Charlotte, the phone rang. G. Kennedy Thompson, who runs the nation’s fourth-largest bank, answered. On the line was John Hammergren, chairman and CEO of San Francisco-based McKesson Corp., North America’s largest pharmaceutical distributor and giant supplier of health-care software, which has been doing business with Wachovia for years. He’s also a director of Hewlett-Packard Co. Starting with its messy ouster of CEO Carly Fiorina in 2005, the Silicon Valley icon’s board had slipped into bickering and backbiting, with nasty leaks to the press, a phone-snooping scandal that led to a federal investigation and several resignations. By the end of last year, it was shopping for a new member to shore up its tattered image. Was Thompson interested?

Indeed he was. Thompson, the bank’s chief executive since 2000, had begun his assault on the West Coast by buying two California-based financial institutions. But those weren’t megadeals, just a beachhead, and getting named an HP director last Nov. 16 raised his and his bank’s profiles in Golden State business circles. "I don’t think it went unnoticed," says Kevin Fitzsimmons, a banking analyst with Sandler O’Neill + Partners in New York. Thompson’s take on it? "It was like a lot of things. I knew John Hammergren very well, and I think he was pushing me there. And then I hit it off nicely with [HP CEO] Mark Hurd."

What looks like serendipity to some seems business as usual to Raleigh investment and merchant banker Lanty Smith, a longtime Wachovia director. "It wasn’t luck at all. He’s outstanding at relationship building because he is such a genuine person. It comes natural to him. He’s been doing it from early on." Tony Plath saw evidence of this skill on a less intimate scale. When the associate professor of finance at UNC Charlotte helped run a bank planning conference in late 1999, he faced an auditorium of glum managers. "People felt abused," he recalls. "It was a harsh place to work." Returning in 2001, "I made some kind of offhanded comment about how people felt beat up and unappreciated, and I distinctly remember some people in the back of the room raising their hands and saying, ‘No, it’s different now.’ I thought, ‘Yeah, right, this is just window dressing.’ But they were right. People were just a lot happier, more optimistic. It was a total reversal of the past culture."

Credit Thompson. He proved not only popular with customers and employees but deft at cleaning up the mess left by Ed Crutchfield, who had cobbled together a giant bank beset by mammoth problems. Thompson, who had worked for First Union Corp. since finishing business school, ironed out widespread customer-service problems and ditched poorly performing businesses. In September 2001, he capped the honeymoon by merging First Union and Winston-Salem-based Wachovia, winning not only its name but what had once been the Southeast’s most respected bank for a bargain price. Analysts lauded the deal as a steal and Thompson as a savior.

But lately, some who had praised his discipline have been spooked. They see the shadow of his old boss, who boasted of piling up billions until a merger target’s resistance collapsed, in Thompson’s willingness to shell out double-digit premiums for SouthTrust Corp., an Alabama bank; Golden West Financial Corp., a California thrift; and A.G. Edwards Inc., the St. Louis-based securities brokerage. "People do not want to see Wachovia make acquisitions," says Richard Bove, a banking analyst with Punk, Ziegel & Co. in New York. "When Crutchfield was around, all he wanted to do was expand as rapidly as possible. What the company is doing now is the Crutchfield strategy."

Thompson considers talk of his metamorphosis amusing. "I am basically the same person now that I was then," he says. "But our company is very different."

Chatting with Thompson, who turns 57 this month, it’s easy to ignore the critics. His low-key charm goes a long way toward explaining his warm relationship with bank staff and his far-flung network of business friendships. He may be a multimillionaire – last year alone, the bank paid him more than $27 million – but he still has the air of an unpretentious small-town guy. He’s smart but not condescending, competitive but not in-your-face aggressive. Crutchfield, a college football player, started his career in the hurly-burly of the bank’s bond-trading floor. Thompson, in contrast, did an early, formative stint as head of human resources. "[Crutchfield] had a mercurial temper," Bove says. "He was a genius, but he was also brutal. Thompson understands that if you motivate employees, make them happy, customers will come back."

He grew up in Rocky Mount, son of a mill manager. Thompson played high-school baseball and football and worked in tobacco warehouses to earn pocket money. Gov. Mike Easley, a schoolmate, recalls him as popular and fun-loving but well-behaved, sticking to soft drinks when others snuck off to buy beer. "When a whole crowd of kids gets together, someone has to be the designated thinker. If Ken was in the group, you knew whatever it was you were doing was OK. He was sort of the Good Housekeeping seal of approval." Easley was taken by surprise when he learned Thompson had won a prestigious Morehead Scholarship to UNC Chapel Hill; Thompson had never let on he was a high-achieving scholar as well as a jock.

During his senior year at Carolina, his mother learned she had cancer. After graduation, he returned to Rocky Mount to spend time with her and his father. He painted houses for about a year and, after his mother died, enrolled in Wake Forest’s business school. Graduating in 1976, he landed a job with First Union. He soon caught Crutchfield’s attention and ended up with a series of increasingly challenging jobs, including the stint as HR chief. "It made me visible to senior management early on, and that clearly didn’t hurt my career," he says. In 1987, Crutchfield sent him to Jacksonville to head First Union’s Florida unit, which was growing quickly on account of all the mergers. The job required knitting a disparate bunch of acquired banks into an efficient operation. He did and was promoted to head of the capital-markets division.

First Union faltered in the late ’90s as Crutchfield’s merger machine sputtered. The bank had gotten too big too fast. Its 1998 acquisition of Philadelphia-based CoreStates Financial Corp. proved especially vexing, with First Union losing more than a fifth of CoreStates’ customers amid operational blunders. First Union stock fell from a high of $65 in 1998 to about $20 by late 2000. As it laid off thousands, morale collapsed, which only compounded the customer-service problems. In March 2000, Crutchfield announced that he had lymphoma and would step down for treatment. He recommended Thompson, who had been named president in 1999 upon John Georgious’ early retirement, as his replacement ("Reluctant Rebel," November 2000). Crutchfield, who has since recovered, is an investor and serves on corporate boards.

Thompson began his tenure by visiting First Union offices around the country. "I was barnstorming," he recalls. "I spent a lot of time talking to and listening to and getting information from people." Under pressure to take drastic action, he didn’t disappoint. Thompson closed The Money Store, a California-based subprime lender acquired less than two years earlier, writing off $1.7 billion as part of $2.8 billion in total restructuring charges. He sold branches, a mortgage-servicing business and credit-card portfolios. He even slashed the dividend – an always unpopular and painful choice for a CEO.

Reversing Crutchfield’s decisions, he never openly criticized his predecessor. The difference in their styles may have been rebuke enough. Crutchfield’s first round of cutbacks had come as a surprise edict, stunning employees. Thompson, in contrast, tried to soften the blow of his by shuttling hundreds of managers to Charlotte for meetings to explain his plan. He would talk 10 to 15 minutes, then take questions. The sessions could hardly be described as upbeat, but at least managers had time to process the idea of layoffs and, just as important, could see that their boss understood the emotional toll.

Thompson cemented his reputation with the rank and file when he promoted popular company veteran Ben Jenkins to head the company’s biggest division, retail banking. He gave him authority to increase staff, hoping to repair the company’s damaged relationship with customers. "Our staffing levels were below those required to get good service," Thompson says. "As hard as people tried, they didn’t have the tools at their fingers. In spite of the fact that our earnings were challenged, we said nothing will work if we don’t give good customer service. So we invested nine-figure dollars in restaffing, in buying tools, buying systems. That was a significant leap of faith on our part."

To ensure that the money was well spent, Jenkins began to devise a series of productivity measurements. Bonuses were tied to good grades. Consistently lousy numbers could get you fired. Tracking performance isn’t unusual, but the speed with which the bank developed and applied its new metrics helped to salvage its reputation with customers. "They can slice and dice every sort of measurement, down to the business level, down to the branch level, down to the teller level," says Fitzsimmons, the banking analyst. "You are constantly seeing what areas are doing well, which are not. You are addressing problems earlier. You are able to weed out underperformers and elevate out-performers faster. Other banks get lots of reports, but here they actually use them. And they focus on the right things."

The turnaround showed up first in happier customers. The bank’s performance on the American Customer Satisfaction Index, a University of Michigan ranking, went from near the bottom among large banks to first place by 2002 and has stayed high. Customer attrition, which stood at an alarming 20% in 1999, began dropping and today is 10%. The tougher task was shoring up the balance sheet. First Union reported net income of $3.2 billion in 1999. But the restructuring, combined with the decline in performance, dashed earnings, and the company ended 2000 with net income of $92 million. Net income bounced back the next year, hitting $1.6 billion. Last year, it was $7.8 billion, $4.63 a share, on revenue of $29.9 billion.

With earnings and the stock rising, Thompson was well situated to do an acquisition – if he dared. An irresistible one came when the company of one of his old business acquaintances found itself in trouble. Despite the competition between their companies, Thompson had long had a rapport with Bud Baker, chief executive of Winston-Salem-based Wachovia. After the old Wachovia saw a sharp increase in problem loans in 2000, their occasional chats turned toward talk of a friendly merger. Thompson offered to pay a modest 6% premium for Wachovia’s stock. A bank its size and historical quality could have commanded two or three times as much. Thompson spent several weeks shuttling between Charlotte and a Comfort Inn in Salisbury, sweet-talking his Wachovia counterparts. He argued that they might find a richer partner but not one that could better merge their operations and serve their shareholders, customers and employees.

Once the banks announced the deal, he had to beat back a rival bid from Atlanta-based SunTrust Banks, which initially came in 10% higher. Thompson put up a pit-bull defense, not only appealing to shareholders but also calling in chits in Raleigh. He persuaded the General Assembly to adopt an emergency bill aimed at weakening SunTrust’s position in the state. The deal closed in September 2001. The combined bank took Wachovia’s name, a concession to its executives – and a convenient way to ditch the tarnished First Union brand. "The Wachovia merger has to be viewed as one of the best in the banking industry," Bove says. Even so, gaining national recognition for the unusual Wachovia name proved a challenge. (People’s initial reaction, inevitably, seems to be, "Wah-CHO-vee-ya? What’s that mean?") Here again, Thompson’s assiduousness in cultivating business relationships paid off.

The PGA Tour is headquartered in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla., near Jacksonville. When based there, Thompson, an 11-handicap golfer, had struck up a friendship with PGA Commissioner Tim Finchem. During a 2002 visit to Jacksonville, they met for breakfast. Finchem mentioned that the Tour might soon make a rare addition to its tournaments. Thompson is a member of Quail Hollow Club in Charlotte, and developer Johnny Harris, the club’s president, was eager to host a PGA event. So Thompson pledged money, Harris offered up the course, and Finchem provided a date. The result: the Wachovia Championship, launched in 2003. "It was a happy confluence of events," Thompson says. "It came up at the same time as the Wachovia merger, and we saw it as a way to brand the name worldwide." This year, 27 of the world’s top 30 players, including Tiger Woods, played, and the event was broadcast globally. Needless to say, the announcers got the name right.

With the Wachovia merger behind him, Thompson started looking to do more deals. In 2004, he found an opportunity in Alabama, buying Birmingham-based SouthTrust. That gave Wachovia a branch network stretching deep into Texas. But it paid dearly – $14.3 billion, a 20% premium. Two years later, in May 2006, came Golden West, which had 285 branches, mostly in its home state. This time, Thompson paid $25.5 billion – a 15% premium. Then, earlier this year, followed A.G. Edwards, for which he offered $6.8 billion – a 16% premium.

Bove, despite his endorsement of the Wachovia-First Union pairing, hasn’t found much to like since. He says SouthTrust cost too much, given its relatively small number of branches in Texas, where Wachovia really needed to be. Golden West delivered a big California footprint but brought a balance sheet gouty with mortgages just as the industry was teetering toward trouble. And A.G. Edwards is the sort of old-fashioned brokerage that’s struggling to compete against low-cost online outfits. "I’m not sure SouthTrust was a good deal," Bove says. "I’m convinced Golden West was not a good deal. And with A.G. Edwards, you are buying a business where you are being undercut by direct-access firms like E*TRADE and Ameritrade. Who needs it?"

Knowing his recent deals aren’t playing well on Wall Street, Thompson is eager to ease concerns. "We have our heads down right now. We are very focused on the integration of Golden West and on the closing of the A.G. Edwards [deal]." At a Lehman Brothers banking conference in September, he put his priorities in plainer language: "We simply aren’t focused on acquisitions." But he insists that success depends on capturing significant shares of new markets. "We have plans for growth in the Southwest and West. Over time, we have plans for growing our percentage of revenue from international markets. If we are successful, we will experience significant growth in earnings, and our shareholders will do extremely well." Deals are part of that plan. He’s convinced that if he moves too slowly Wachovia will be left behind. Bank of America blanketed California by way of one big merger – the one in which it got its latest name – in 1998. These days, it’s not only the nation’s second-largest bank but one of the better-run ones; its return on common equity in 2006 was 16%, compared with Wachovia’s 14%.

Judging by his compensation, Wachovia’s board believes in Thompson’s strategy. According to the latest Business North Carolina CEO pay survey, he pulled down $27.8 million in salary, bonuses, stock and options last year, second in the state and slightly more than BofA CEO Ken Lewis received. "It was a troubled company when he took over," Lanty Smith says. "Look at the stock price today and when he went into the job. Wachovia and Ken’s performance look very competitive and attractive." The share price has increased, but given how badly the bank was faring then, that seems cold comfort. Over the last five years, it has only barely bested the Dow Jones bank stock index. Over the last two – during the period of the Golden West and A.G. Edwards deals – it has fallen short of it. So far this year, as the index has dropped, Wachovia’s price has fallen farther, losing more than 9% of its value through the beginning of October.

As shares slumped, Thompson has met with analysts and investors to evangelize. He concedes that Golden West brought with it a sharp rise in problem loans – Wachovia set aside $179 million in the second quarter to cover future losses, triple the amount set aside a year earlier. But he says his bank’s size should allow it to easily absorb losses. And with many lenders leaving the mortgage industry in the recent shakeout, Wachovia should be poised for growth as a survivor in a decimated market. As for A.G. Edwards, it will create the nation’s second-largest brokerage and add to the company’s bottom line with a little sales training for its brokers. "Earnings can be enhanced simply by increasing A.G. Edwards’s productivity to Wachovia Securities standards," Thompson told the crowd at the Lehman conference. Why he paid a hefty premium for a less productive outfit remains an open question.

Deal making, he adds, represents only part of his expansion strategy. The bank also is building branches in Texas, California and New York and investing in high-profile marketing. This summer, for example, Wachovia put its name on concerts and other events at the Staples Center in Los Angeles.

His HP duties will add to an already busy travel schedule. He spends about half his time traveling, mainly between Wachovia offices on a company jet. When not poring over company reports, his reading tends toward history and biography. He recently finished Why Elephants Can’t Dance, former IBM Chairman Lou Gerstner’s account of his company’s turnaround, and was one of the first in line for Alan Greenspan’s The Age of Turbulence: Adventures in a New World. In it, the former Fed chairman describes what he calls "irrational exuberance." Sunny though his views on his recent deals might be, Thompson won’t see any resemblance.

Feedback + Comments

First Name :
Last Name :
Company Name :
E-mail address :
Title of Article :
Comment on this article :